Brought
to you by:
Brought
to you by:

Maryland Attorney General Announces Review Process for 41 Restraint-Related Deaths

Maryland Flag

The Maryland Office of the Attorney General has announced a framework for transparency, family notification and public accountability as it reviews 41 restraint-related deaths.

A 2025 audit of the Maryland Office of the Chief Medical Examiner determined the deaths should have been classified as homicides. The Attorney General’s review will determine whether the evidence in each case warrants reopening the matter for further criminal investigation.

Case reviews are ongoing. As each review is completed, the Office of the Attorney General said it will make every effort to directly notify the decedent’s family.

Families and their attorneys, when applicable, will receive a written letter outlining the results of the preliminary review. They will have 30 days to submit additional information or materials they believe may be relevant to determining potential criminal liability.

After that 30-day period, and after reviewing any materials submitted, the office will make a final determination and notify the family before issuing any public statement.

The Office of the Attorney General will then issue an individual press release announcing the findings for each case. Families will also be offered the opportunity to personally review the investigative case file.

Attorney General Anthony Brown said the office recognizes the grief carried by the families of the 41 decedents as they wait for more information about their loved ones’ final moments.

Maryland is the first state in the nation to conduct a review of this kind, according to the Office of the Attorney General. The office said it cannot provide a projected end date because each case has distinct facts, evidence and circumstances.

In May 2025, Brown and Gov. Wes Moore released a 70-page audit report reviewing in-custody death determinations made by the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner between 2003 and 2019.

From more than 1,300 in-custody deaths investigated by the medical examiner’s office, the Audit Design Team selected 87 cases involving deaths during or after restraint for independent review.

Key findings from the audit included:

  • In 44 of the 87 cases reviewed, one or more of three independent forensic reviewers disagreed with the original determination of the manner of death.
  • In 36 cases, all three independent reviewers unanimously concluded the death should have been classified as a homicide.
  • In five additional cases, two of three reviewers concluded the death should have been classified as a homicide.

According to the National Association of Medical Examiners, the classification of manner of death is not a legal conclusion. A death is classified as a homicide when it results from a volitional act committed by another person. The classification does not establish criminal intent or criminal culpability.

Since the audit findings were released in 2025, the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner has not changed the manner or cause of death certification in any of the 41 cases, according to the Attorney General’s Office.

The 41 Cases Under Review

The following individuals are the 41 decedents whose cases are being reviewed under Moore’s executive order. Cases marked “Homicide” reflect a unanimous determination by all three independent reviewers. Cases marked “No Consensus” reflect a determination by two of three independent reviewers that the manner of death should have been classified as homicide.

County refers to the jurisdiction listed by the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner on the cover page of the autopsy report, which may differ from the county where the death occurred or where the restraint occurred.

NameYear of DeathCountyOCME MODAudit MOD
Shawn Floyd2018Anne ArundelUndeterminedHomicide
Gregory Williams2003Baltimore CityUndeterminedNo Consensus (2 of 3)
Shawn Bryant2004Baltimore CityUndeterminedNo Consensus (2 of 3)
Rodney Wilson2005Baltimore CityUndeterminedHomicide
Dondi Johnson2005Baltimore CityAccidentHomicide
William Washington2006Baltimore CityUndeterminedHomicide
Carlos Branch2007Baltimore CityUndeterminedHomicide
Thomas Campbell2007Baltimore CityUndeterminedHomicide
Eric Dorsey2011Baltimore CityNaturalHomicide
Don Thomas2011Baltimore CityUndeterminedHomicide
Jontae Daughtry2011Baltimore CityUndeterminedHomicide
Tyrone West2013Baltimore CityUndeterminedHomicide
Ricky Artis2014Baltimore CityUndeterminedHomicide
George King2014Baltimore CityNaturalHomicide
Antonio Moreno2014Baltimore CityUndeterminedHomicide
Thomas Rawls2006Baltimore CountyUndeterminedHomicide
Ryan Meyers2007Baltimore CountyUndeterminedHomicide
Carl Johnson2010Baltimore CountyUndeterminedHomicide
Mary Croker2010Baltimore CountyUndeterminedHomicide
Tawon Boyd2016Baltimore CountyAccidentHomicide
Dominic Edwards2018CarrollUndeterminedHomicide
Jarrel Gray2007FrederickUndeterminedHomicide
Anthony Casarella2007FrederickUndeterminedHomicide
Terrance Watts2018FrederickAccidentHomicide
David Matarazzo2007HarfordUndeterminedNo Consensus (2 of 3)
George Barnes2007MontgomeryUndeterminedHomicide
Kareem Ali2010MontgomeryUndeterminedHomicide
Delric East2011MontgomeryAccidentHomicide
Anthony Howard2013MontgomeryUndeterminedHomicide
Ricardo Manning2019MontgomeryUndeterminedHomicide
Cedric Gilmore2004Prince George’sUndeterminedHomicide
James Jackson2003Prince George’sUndeterminedHomicide
Marcus Skinner2007Prince George’sUndeterminedNo Consensus (2 of 3)
Alexis Caston2007Prince George’sUndeterminedHomicide
Deontre Dorsey2015Prince George’sUndeterminedHomicide
Anton Black2018CarolineAccidentHomicide
Theodore Rosenberry2006WashingtonUndeterminedHomicide
James Adell2013WashingtonUndeterminedNo Consensus (2 of 3)
Darrell Brown2015WashingtonUndeterminedHomicide
Ronald Byler2005WicomicoUndeterminedHomicide
Yekuna McDonald2012WorcesterUndeterminedHomicide

Families who believe their loved one’s case was impacted by the audit can contact the Office of the Attorney General through the OCME Audit Hotline.

Email: OCMEAuditHotline@oag.state.md.us
Phone: 833-282-0961

David W. Wood 1950-2026

David enjoyed many things throughout his life, including model planes and cars, hunting, fishing, and working with his hands.

Mary C. Plank 1937-2026

Mary dedicated many years of her life serving as a certified nurse’s aide, providing compassionate care to those in need.

Mark Alan Stoddard 1959-2026

Born on December 19, 1959, Mark was the son of the late George Otis Stoddard, Sr. and Sandra Elizabeth (Robinson) Stoddard.

Donna L. Rebuck 1939-2026

Donna was known for her kindness, creativity, and beautiful artwork—decorative pieces, watercolors, and acrylic paintings.

Lee Wayne VanTine 1946-2026

Though quiet and reserved by nature, Lee possessed a gentle spirit and a steady presence that brought comfort to those around him.

Fleeing and eluding

Chambersburg Police Department is attempting to identify the subject involved in a fleeing and eluding incident involving a black e-bike. Chambersburg Police are attempting to identify the individual photographed below.

Who We Are

The Franklin County Free Press, established by Vicky Taylor in 2019, emerged as a beacon of local journalism for the residents of Franklin County. Under Vicky's leadership, it quickly became an essential source of news, particularly at a time when major newspaper publications were increasingly overlooking local coverage.

On January 1, 2022, the torch was passed to Nathan Neil and his firm, Neil Publishing, LLC. Neil, a local entrepreneur with multiple thriving businesses in Chambersburg, shares Vicky's fervent commitment to both the community and the world of local journalism.

Rooted in the heart of Franklin County and powered by its residents, the Franklin County Free Press continues to bridge the gap, ensuring that the local stories, events, and issues that matter most to the community remain in the spotlight.